Some recent developments

I am at our cash office, taking out some money. H, the diminutive finance officer asks me about my family back in Australia. He tells me his maternal uncle’s son has lived in Australia for the last 25 years.  I suggest that the maternal uncle’s son come back to Afghanistan and contribute to the rebuilding and rejuvenating of the country. H tells me that he did return recently, for a short while: ‘He said that in all the things he saw, only one thing had improved over the last 25 years.’

‘And that was?’

‘You can get good bread here now.’

I ponder this as I go upstairs. Part of me rejects it as a cynical comment, tossed off without thought. Of course if you left here in the early 80s, before the country was shot to pieces and if your baseline is Melbourne, then current Afghanistan does not compare favourably. But his remark reflects a deeper truth, which is that Afghanistan has dropped a long, long way from the high watermark of the early 70s, and it has not recovered. 35 years of conflict and still counting, we should not be surprised at the slow rate of change.

That said, there is plenty of evidence of similar cynicism: a friend sat next to a leader from the Panjshir Valley on a flight recently, and this leader told him how they have a shadow Government, primed and prepared to take over as soon as Kabul falls. These are not Talibs, but Tajiks. Competent, probably, and long-sighted, they are planning for the next decade. In contrast, aid donors and military planners think in terms of the next 6 months. There are multiple such shadow Government structures all around the country.


The ditches being dug around the place that I referred to earlier: an interesting aspect to these is that the drains used to be regarded more or less as the property or responsibility of the adjacent householder. Now that some donor has paid for the municipality to subcontract their construction, the ownership and maintenance of these ditches has become unclear. As a result, no one is cleaning them out. For most of the year they collect rubbish, rocks, dead animals. But when it snows – then they block, and flood. Was this foreseeable? Could a better process have ensured community ownership of the ditches? Because while a donor was happy to pay for their construction, no one has the money or willingness to pay for their ongoing care.

They do serve the purpose though of allowing you to shake your carpets out.

Meanwhile, it has snowed. This cleared the air and created a whole big great wonderful lot of fun.

Then it snowed more and yesterday when we woke up there was a foot or so on the ground. The children were delirious with excitement.

Easy for us to enjoy it, with barrels to kerosene to fill our heaters with, and thick snow clothes inherited from our Swedish friends. Not so much fun for poor Afghans. We have had a few requests for help, and have given away a bunch of clothes and jackets, following St Basil’s admonition:

‘The bread which you do not eat is the bread of the hungry; the coat hanging in the wardrobe is the coat of the one who is naked and cold; the shoes you do not wear are the shoes of the one who is barefoot; the money you keep locked away is the money of the poor; the acts of charity you do not perform are the many injustices that you commit.’ 

We know that giving away money and clothes is a short term solution. It is, however, a solution to those who would otherwise go hungry and cold, until a better solution can be found. And that is not going to be anytime soon, here.

Finally, the Government must have decided that ‘illegal’ roadside installations are to be eliminated, because all the nice little shops and so on along the streets have been torn down. The guard boxes are being repositioned, as you can see. I can’t see this working for the shopkeepers though.

5 thoughts on “Some recent developments

  1. Was he/are you saying that things are (getting) worse? Generally – apart from the bread.

    I love the photo of the snowman and singer… and I’d hate to have to haul a two-year old out of one of those ditches…

  2. The apparent contrast I see in your photos makes me happy and sad. The usefulness of the ditch being summed up as serving “the purpose though of allowing you to shake your carpets out.” Not at all up to their original purpose. And, the sweet photos of your children and the cleansing power of snow. Interesting the man noticed the positive change of bread. This brought to mind all kinds of spiritual references to me.

  3. For several years I have been teaching English via Skype from Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia, Canada to students at the Afghan-Canadian Community Center
    ( ) in Kandahar .

    I recently sent by Western Union a small amount of cash to my student that converted to about $ 1500.00 Afghani dollars(AFN) to buy some fuel . How much does a typical Afghan pay per month to heat a small house? How do they typically heat their houses in Kandahar – i.e. wood? propane ? How much does a small Kerosene heater cost in Kandahar ? Do they sell wool sweaters/hats/mittens/socks in the local markets ? If so what would $1500.00 (AFN) buy ?

    You have an incredible site and I am definitely bookmarking it !! Thank you so much for doing it.

    Best regards from Barbara
    March 4, 2012

    • Hi Barbara,
      Thanks for making contact.
      A few responses – in Kandahar, the winters are far less severe than other parts of the country. This winter has been particularly harsh, and so in Kabul, about 1500-2000 Afs has been just sufficient for a month’s heating. In Kandahar, 1500Afs would be enough for heating with some left over, and in a less severe winter, it would be ample.
      While I haven’t been to Kandahar in winter, I would be confident that like Kabul, wood is generally used for heating. Coal and diesel are the other main alternatives. Gas is rarely used by poorer people; it is used in offices and by wealthier people.
      I would be very confident that mittens, socks etc are all available in the markets in Kandahar. Basically these days, if there is a demand, the supply will arise to meet it. The only places that doesn’t apply is in the really remote parts of Afghanistan. Kandahar is well connected to Pakistan via Quetta, and so has good supply routes. Chinese and locally made mittens, hats, shawls etc – you can find it all.
      Hope that helps, and it is good that you check such things, too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s